欢迎光临散文网 会员登陆 & 注册

GM Foods: What Are the Pros and Cons? 转基因食物的优缺点

2022-10-26 10:23 作者:三十名八千里  | 我要投稿





Engineers design plants that use genetically modified organisms (GMOs) to be tougher, more nutritious or taste better. However, people are worried about their safety, and there is a lot of discussion about the pros and cons of using GMOs.

转基因工程设计师设计新品种的植物,这些植物的大多器官与之前的相比更加坚韧,更加的营养富足,有更好的口感。然而人们更关心转基因植物的安全性问题,一直以来关于转基因食物的纷争不断。

Scientists produce genetically modified foods by genetically engineering genetic engineering to obtain genetic material or DNA from another organism.

科学家将不同的物种的DNA切割混合,用基因工具改造原种

Most of the genetically modified foods currently available are plants such as fruits and vegetables.

大多数被设计的而且目前可获得的转基因食物是转基因的水果和蔬菜。

In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates all foods made from genetically modified plants. They must meet the same safety requirements as non-GMO foods.

在美国,美国国家食品药品管理局对转基因食品做出规范。转基因食品必须满足食品安全规范的若干条例。

GM foods could become an important tool for feeding a growing world population, especially in areas with harsh climates. However, there are concerns about potential risks.

转基因食品对于喂养日益增长的人口发挥越来越大的作用,特别是在一些严苛环境中。尽管如此,还是普遍存在关于转基因食品潜在风险的担忧。

In this article, we discuss the benefits and harms of genetically modified plants, including their potential impact on human health and the environment.

在这篇文章中我们将全面讨论转基因植物的优劣,包括它们对人类健康以及自然的潜在影响。

Advantage

优点

Manufacturers use genetic alterations to give food products the desired properties.

转基因领域的科学家使用DNA可局部替换的特性给予食物以预期的性状,客观上达到了人类的目的。

Potential benefits of genetically modified plants include:

转基因食物的隐藏的好处:

Increased appeal to consumers, such as apples and potatoes, is less likely to bruise or turn brown

增加了消费市场的长期活力,例如转基因苹果和土豆更加难以变质。

Intensifier Flavor

改变了味道

Longer shelf life, thus reducing waste

增长了保质期,因此减少了浪费

Stronger resistance to viruses and other diseases, which can lead to less waste and higher food security, and higher tolerance to herbicides ,making it easier for farmers to control weeds

 

增强了对植物对疾病和病毒的抵抗性,这有助于减少浪费,提高食物安全性,以及增强对除草剂的抵抗性 , 使农民更加容易控制杂草。

Increasing nutritional value, such as golden rice, can improve the health of people who have difficulty accessing food as well

This can enable farmers to reduce their use of pesticides

Heat capacity to grow on saline soils

使得食物有更丰富的营养,例如黄金稻米,不仅可以改善对获取食物有困难的人的健康,也可以减少杀虫剂的使用,使植物在严苛的环境下也能生存,特别是在盐碱地和高温。

Growing plants that are more resistant to diseases carried by insects or viruses may lead to higher yields and more attractive products for farmers.

种植可以抵抗病虫害,可以抵抗疾病的植物会有更高亩产,这对农民来讲非常具有吸引力。

All of these factors help reduce costs for consumers and ensure that more people have access to high-quality food.

所有的这些因素都可以减少成本,也可以确保更多人可以获得高质量农产品。

Shortcoming

缺点

Genetically modified foods are a relatively new practice, meaning the long-term impact on safety is unclear.

多数转基因食品是相对新的尝试,这意味着长期影响尚不清楚。

Many concerns about shortcomings are related to human health. Scientists have yet to prove that genetically modified foods are harmful to health, but research is underway.

许多人都担忧转基因食品的缺点会有害人类健康,但科学的研究还没有表明它们的确如此。

Anaphylaxis

过敏反应

The risk of allergic reactions from genetically modified foods is small. However, this only happens when a genetic change triggers the production of an allergen.

转基因食品的过敏反应出现的概率很小。但不意味着绝对不会发生,实际上过敏只会发生在基因改变触发 过敏原产生效应器

For example, when scientists combined the genes of Brazil nuts with soybeans, people with nut allergies were less likely to develop allergic reactions to products made from soybeans.

例如当科学家将巴西栗与大豆(或黄豆)的基因混合,对坚果过敏的人对这个新品种有更低的概率发作过敏

The World Health Organization (WHO) advises genetic engineers not to use DNA from allergens unless they can prove that the gene itself is not the cause of the problem.

世界卫生组织建议基因工程师不要使用过敏源的DNA片段,除非他们能确定该基因片段不是导致过敏的原因。

Scientists have assessed the likelihood that genetically modified foods trigger human allergic reactions before the product hits the market and prevent it from entering the market if necessary.

在转基因食品进入市场前相关人员对其进行检查,评估导致过敏的可能性,阻止不合格产品进入市场等步骤是必要的。

Cancer

癌症

There are concerns that eating genetically modified foods may increase levels of potential carcinogens in the body, leading to the development of cancer.

对于转基因食品是否会导致人体内潜在的致癌物质的积累,进而导致癌症这一疑惑仍然存在担忧。

The American Cancer Society notes that there is currently no evidence that genetically modified foods available can increase or decrease the risk of cancer.

美国癌症协会指出:目前没有证据表明目前市场上的转基因食品会增加或减少癌症的获得性风险。也就是说目前的证据表明:转基因食品与癌症没有明显的关系。

While cancer rates in the U.S. have changed over time, there is no evidence that these changes coincide with the introduction of genetically modified foods. If there is a connection, it may take several years for the trend to emerge.

尽管癌症在美国的比例已经时过境迁,还是没有证据表明这些改变是由于转基因食品的引入而导致的。尽管可能在情理上会有联系,但事实上从转基因技术出现到现在还没有水滴石穿,真相大白的趋势。

Antibacterial properties

抗菌能力

Some GMOs contain changes that make them resistant to certain antibiotics. Theoretically, if the genes of these plants eat them, they will enter humans or animals. As a result, humans or animals may also develop antibiotic resistance.

一些转基因食品由于部分改变使得它们有对目的细菌的抵抗性,从理论上讲最后由于食物链的传递方向,这些基因片段会进入动物体和人体中。结果会使人体具有部分的抗菌能力。

The likelihood of this happening is very low, but WHO and other health agencies have developed guidelines to prevent this from happening.

这个事故发生的可能性很低,但是世界卫生组织和其他健康机构还是出台了准则来阻止此类事故的发生。

Changes in human genes

改变人类基因

In 2009, some food scientists discovered that food DNA can survive all the way to the gut, and some people worry that this is the immune system.

在2009年,一些食物科学家发现食物中的DNA会幸存在人类的肠道之中,这导致了一些人担忧这会对免疫系统造成影响。

Some have also expressed concern that eating genetically modified foods could lead to genetic changes in humans. However, most of the DNA in food — whether GMO or not — is either destroyed by cooking or broken down before reaching the large intestine.

一些人也表明担忧对食用转基因食物是否会改变人体基因组这一问题。

然而大多数食物中的DNA,无论是否为转基因食物,摆在前面的无非是在烹饪中被毁坏,或是在到达大肠前被分解。(所以不加烹饪的沙拉是有风险的做法,最好是先加热一遍,而且大部分蔬菜生吃的味道并不太好,而且无法避免的会有杂菌,病毒等致病因子存留其上)

Small DNA fragments from food can and will enter the bloodstream and body organs, but there is no evidence that they have an effect on genetic material or human health.

一些来自食物的小的DNA片段可以静入血流中,人体器官中,但没有证据表明它们会对人的遗传物质或是人体健康有影响。

Toxicity to body organs

对人体器官的毒性

In 2009, some researchers proposed that genetically modified foods could affect the liver, kidneys, pancreas, and reproductive systems. They have no evidence to confirm this and call for further study.

在2009年,一些研究员声称转基因食物会对肝,肾脏,胰腺,生殖系统等产生影响。但美中不足的是,他们既没有证据来确认自己的结论,也没有可以用于进一步探索的相关资料。

Using GM crops can even reduce the risk of toxicity of certain substances, as farmers can avoid using pesticides that used to be harmful.

让人大跌眼镜的是,使用转基因作物反而可以减少某些有毒物质的影响,从根本上使得农民减少或停止使用有毒的农药。

Are GM foods good or bad for the environment?

转基因食物对环境是好是坏?

Climate change and severe weather events are disrupting food production and supply. In the face of changing environmental conditions and a growing population, genetically modified foods can help maintain supply.

全球气候变暖,极端天气增多对食物的生产供应造成破坏。在面对多变的气候和日益增多的人口,转基因食品可以帮助维持食品供给。

advantage

this

Generatively modifying certain foods can make them easier

Storage and transportation

有特定目的的转基因食物可以更好的储存和运输

be

It is not easy to waste due to disease and aging

更强的对疾病的抵抗性,更不易衰老

Yes, it

More likely, they will be located in areas with poor soil quality, and more higher nutrient content

可以被种在贫瘠的土壤,有更高的营养物含量

grow

A 2022 study suggests that genetically modified foods can help mitigate climate change:

一项2022年的研究表明转基因食物可以帮助应对气候改变

Shortcoming

缺点:

Environmental issues include:

环境问题包括:

The risk of hybridization, in which genes from genetically modified foods are transferred to wild plants and other crops

,It has a negative impact on the following aspects

Reduce insects and other species in other plant types, leading to biodiversity loss

杂交的风险,杂交种的优势取代会使原种的相对资源减少,客观上打破了基因多样性的平衡,使原进化方向和食物链发生改变。

Risks vary depending on local circumstances.

风险与当地气候相关

Identification of genetically modified foods

鉴定转基因食物

In the United States, the FDA does not require genetically modified foods to have special labels. This is because they must meet the same safety standards as other food products and do not require additional regulations.

在美国,美国食品药品管理局没有要求一定给转基因食物贴上特殊标签。这是因为这些转基因食品满足安全标准,就和别的产品一样不需要额外的规定。

However, if genetically modified foods are "significantly" different from conventional foods, special labels are required.

然而,如果转基因食品与传统食品显著不同,特殊标签也是会被要求的。

For example:

例如:

A genetically modified canola oil that contains more lauric acid than traditional canola oil is labeled "laurate canola oil".

一种转基因菜籽油,特别之处在于比传统品种有更高含量的月桂酸,所以被叫做“月桂酸菜籽油”。

A GMO soybean oil with more oleic acid than GMO-free soybean oil must be labelled as “soybean oil with a high oil content”

一种转基因大豆油,有更多的油酸,必须被贴标签“高含油量大豆油”A GMO soybean oil with a high content of stearidonic acid, which does not occur naturally in oil, must be labelled with “stearidonate soybean oil”

转基因大豆油由于有高含量的硬脂二酸, 硬脂二酸不会自然出现在天然油脂中,所以这种大豆油必须被提前告知消费者为“硬脂二酸大豆油”。

However, the 2018 National Bioengineered Food Disclosure Standard states that all foods that contain genetically modified ingredients must now bear the label “derived from bioengineering” or “bioengineered.” Specific symbols indicate whether a food was produced using biotechnology.

然而在2008年国家生物工程食品标准规定所有来自转基因技术的食品必须带有明显的相关标识。具体标志表明一个食品是否使用生物技术。

How to find GMO-free food

如何找到非转基因食物

which are produced using biotechnology, and products containing bioengineered foods must bear a specific label. If a product does not have such a label, it does not contain any bio-engineered ingredients.

生产加工涉及生物技术必须带有标识。如果一个产品没有此类标识,那么就不会有任何生物工程的成分。

Foods that are likely to be GMOs include:

可能是转基因食品包括:

Sugar beets, as 99.9% of sugar beets in the USA are GMO rapeseed products

甜菜,在美国99.9%的甜菜都是生物工程的产物。

大豆,美国95%的大豆是转基因食品

because 95% of them in US soybeans are genetically engineered

Products are changed as 94% of soybeans in the USA

GMO corn is GMO cottonseed oil, as 92% of corn planted in the USA

棉花,94%的棉花是生物工程产物

Because 94% of cotton is GMOs

Many GMO plants also become ingredients in other foods, for example:

许多转基因植物的作用就是为其他食物的制作提供原料例如:

cornstarch in soups and sauces

汤和酱汁中的玉米淀粉

corn syrup used as a sweetener

用作甜味剂的玉米糖浆

corn, rapeseed and soybean oil in mayonnaise, dressings and bread sugar

蛋黄酱、调味料和面包糖中的玉米、油菜籽和大豆油

from sugar beets

 来自甜菜

How do scientists produce GMO foods?

科学家如何制作转基因食品

When genetically modified, scientists add new DNA to the gene pool of an existing plant.

科学家寻求现有的植物的部分基因来添加到目的植株以达到相应的性状。

To do this, the following must happen

Scientists transfer new DNA to plant cells.

为了完成转基因的操作,科学家必须去做:

科学家将其他物种的DNA片段移植到该植株

They grow the cells in tissue cultures and a plant develops.

通过培养细胞达到组织层次,之后利用植物组织培养技术培育有相应性状的新品种植物。

The new plant produces seeds.

新植物产出种子

A person grows plants from the new seeds.

人们从这些新植物产生的种子来种植庄稼。

The new plants will have genetic characteristics that make them more nutritious or resistant to pests, diseases or climate factors, for example.

新的植物将会有基因层次的改变,由于基因对性状有显著影响,会使得现有的植株更加有营养,或是有更强的对害虫的抵抗性,对疾病的抵抗性,对气候因素的稳定性,例如:

For thousands of years, people have used methods such as selective breeding or crossing to produce more viable plants. However, it took a long time for changes to be made and it was difficult to make specific changes.

千百年来,人们使用诸如择优选择(非自然选择),杂交育种来培育更多更优的植物。然而,这一过程是漫长而枯燥的,而且培育往往具有盲目,不完全定向而导致复杂的特性。

In recent years, developments in genetic engineering have enabled scientists to make specific changes more quickly. The plants produced in this way are referred to as GMO plants. The first GMO food that came on the market in 1994 was a tomato.

在这几年,生物工程迅速发展使得科学家能够更快地制作特定的改变。这种方法制作的植物称为转基因植物。世界上第一种进入市场的转基因植物是1994年的西红柿。

Types of GMO foods

转基因食物的类型

The following are the most common GMO plants produced and sold in the USA:

下面的是最常见的转基因植物:

sugar beet,

甜菜

Rapeseed, Maize Potato

 

油菜籽玉米,土豆

summer squash ,papaya,apple,Alfalfa

夏南瓜,木瓜,苹果,苜蓿

Derivatives of these foods, such as corn starch and sugar, are also found in other manufactured foods. It’s worth noting that 99.9% of all sugar beets harvested in the USA are genetically modified, as are over 90% of all canola, corn, soybean, and cotton varieties.

由这些植物制作的食品,例如玉米淀粉和糖类,都被发现在其他的转基因食品里。值得一提的是,美国99.9%的甜菜都是生物工程制作,同时也有超过90%的油菜,玉米,大豆,和各种棉花等。




Frequently asked questions

常见的问题

Below, we answer a few questions that people often ask about GMO foods.

接下来我们会回答一些人们经常会问起的问题

Which common foods are GMOs?

常见的哪些食品是转基因食品

The probability that foods made from corn, cottonseed, soybeans, canola, or sugar beets are GMO foods in the USA is 90% or higher.

在美国由玉米, 棉籽,大豆,油菜,或甜菜做成的食物是转基因的可能性在90%或者更高。

Which GMO foods should be avoided?

我们应该避免哪一种转基因食物呢?

There are no specific GMO foods that should be avoided. GMO foods are rigorously tested before they can be marketed. It could also make them safer than other foods that are not tested.

实际上去刻意躲避某种转基因食物是没有必要的。转基因食物在投入市场前都会被严格检测,这使得它们比那些没有被测试的食物更加可靠。

Is GMO food safe?

转基因食品安全吗?

There is currently no evidence that GMO foods cause cancer, allergies, or other health problems. However, the research is still ongoing.

目前没有证据表明转基因食物会导致癌症,过敏,或者其他健康问题。但是研究还在继续。

What are the risks of GMO foods?

转基因食品的风险在于?

Health authorities are checking all GMOs and other foods for safety before manufacturers can sell them, and research is ongoing.

相关的国家部门会对转基因食品在厂家销售前进行检测,目的是为了确保安全。相关研究一直在进行着。

To date, scientists have found no evidence that commercially available GMO foods are harmful to health. Environmental concerns include the risk of altered genes entering wild species.

目前为止,科学家还没有发现市场上流通的转基因食品对健康有害的证据。环境方面的担忧包括这些被改变的基因进入野生本种之中,使得自然进化的方向出现矛盾。

Outlook

未来展望

Genetic changes can make plants resistant to diseases and herbicides. Therefore, the process can increase the amount of food that farmers can grow. This in turn can lower food prices and contribute to food security.

基因的改变使得这些植株具有优良的性状,从而增加亩产。而且转基因植株反过来会降低食物价格,而且还会保证食物安全。

GMO plants are relatively new, and researchers are still investigating their long-term safety and health effects, but there is still no evidence that currently available GMO foods are harmful to human health.

转基因技术的出现还不久,所以研究人员还在持续地调查他们的长期安全问题和对健康的影响,目下并没有证据表明市场上流通的转基因食品会对人体造成什么负面影响。





但是还躺在实验室的转基因食品的风险肯定是比市场上的高,不建议直接使用实验室的转基因食品,还有最好不要在实验室吃东西,嘿嘿。

 

#找不到原文,诶,实在是一桩憾事


GM Foods: What Are the Pros and Cons? 转基因食物的优缺点的评论 (共 条)

分享到微博请遵守国家法律