{"ops":[{"insert":"小小蹭个热度～最近仍然不爱看国产都市剧的我，在微博热搜上看到了《东八区的先生们》下架的消息，一时好奇就了解了一下。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/watermark/5d6aa13d4e1a1f37c9d29a6ce51dd3bf976109c8.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":581245,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"这一下子好家伙，直接把我雷翻了...因为我注意到这部剧除了被大家诟病的油腻、物化女性、脱离现实诸多毛病以外，还涉及到了抄袭啊！不知有没有小伙伴也看过2012年播出的韩剧《绅士的品格》，这两部剧里有太多框架雷同的地方了！合着张导10年磨一剑真是精确计算过的时间是吧！\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/watermark/3de576dddbbeecc9c3250e48816e870c888d86f8.jpg","width":1919,"height":1080,"size":825101,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"男性群像剧其实已经陆续拍过很多了，但为什么我会在只看了东八的部分内容后就会联想到《绅士的品格》(以下简称为绅品)，实在是一些镜头，整体框架，故事背景设定，从少年到中年的时间线都太像了。绅品中精华的部分全没学会，拿了个骨架之后就乱贴！以至于说东八翻拍都是对绅品的不尊重。那么咱们就来浅谈一下他们之间相似和截然相反的地方吧。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/1c6147e84e57352581bc93c231d96b7c30301e8f.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":872546,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"上面是绅品开场，下面是东八的开场。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/e744aa63ec5a597ad1225d364ed1e5a22272f1dc.jpg","width":1645,"height":1080,"size":648284,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"构图很有镜像翻转感吧，而且巧合的是，绅品开场是参加同学的葬礼，东八是参加婚礼，也是镜像翻转一般的对比。\n绅品主要讲述的是从学生时代就是死党的四个刚刚迈入不惑之年的男人，在男孩与男人身份的转换之期，分别遇到了改变自己人生并且让自己变得更成熟更有担当的爱人，最后由4变8，磕磕绊绊却幸福地走下去的故事。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/8f207855fe79b3e665ace0536346fedd9b9fd66b.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1179876,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"虽然都是事业有成，可也有区别。一直品学兼优的崔润成为了优秀的律师，学建筑的金道振和林泰山在经历两次创业失败后经营着一家小有规模的建筑公司，李正录是最不学无术的，可是呢娶了个富婆姐姐，不仅自己可以悠闲的当咖啡店长，还顺便解决了好友们的工作室房租问题。没有详细介绍大学生活，更着重于中学时代，避开了专业不一致的bug。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/aa7f200c165fbafc5c54e596487bbaf6141bafea.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1106719,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"反观东八，一个大学寝室能出来AI工程师，大学教授，品牌店长和西餐厨师，这样全面且有个性的大学务必告诉我是哪一所谢谢😓\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/8e76ff1e42dcdde9c4ebc1a9613ec32c21219f38.jpg","width":640,"height":362,"size":200517,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"区别于绅品每一集开头一个记忆片段的形式，东八开篇交代了学生时代的记忆，可能是想立下他们之间友谊的基础吧，是四个人和别校学生打架的事件。被教导主任逼问谁先动手。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/70975e4e4a639fa205e27421f5453fcc0fb389ee.jpg","width":1780,"height":1080,"size":692767,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"上是东八被训话的场景，下是绅品的场景\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/e219bfd7bfc4a16fac9b9cad8aab09fdc5f9a04b.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":943740,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"而这种学生时代一起受训的桥段，巧了，绅品里面也有，而且比起东八假道学的一套说辞，更有时代特点。这一段是描写四个人偷偷看小电影被教导主任发现，询问主谋时三个损友陷害正录(最右)背锅受罚的搞笑回忆。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/4459bedf4dd12ec68ccddd88d449778954886663.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1079061,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"这两个片段的很多镜头，构图非常相似，包括老师的站位和角度都很一致。只不过东八的情节没有绅品的那么饱满有趣罢了。而且还贡献了让人辣眼睛的“金句”\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/84af01d8d2d3411aef0386b8ada760591f3530f7.jpg","width":1269,"height":924,"size":461416,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"请问你们把女性当做什么了？😡\n不过这种道德底线问题，已经有太多吐槽了。我就不再赘述，只能说编剧的脑子好像有那个大病。😇\n说回开头吧。一个葬礼一个婚礼，构图学了，立意一点没学。绅品开头借着葬礼的一场闹剧，突出了四个男人到了中年，已经不再是毛头小子，突发状况也好荒唐不堪也好，都能维持风度进行妥善的回应。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/57f36ef238bb4e5c6f1aa6f0fc5e4c489fea9ef2.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1059940,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"东八的开头实在不太懂，就为了烘托他们，事业有成？坐直升机参加婚礼，一堆外国人伴娘与宾客？\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/da277b11f592ece27894b52bf8c6de539dd6c49e.jpg","width":1871,"height":1080,"size":698936,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"看不起我们中国的女孩子吗？我们中国女生不美吗？不配参加婚礼吗？\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/f8de759e6a2d0ede390807f52ed6f706dd3cef94.jpg","width":1765,"height":996,"size":917043,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"还特别给了外国女宾这种惊喜向往的特写镜头，说实话如果我参加户外婚礼看见有人坐直升机过来搅动一片暴风尘土，很可能用看智障的眼神对他们行注目礼。知道的是来观礼，不知道的以为是砸场抢亲来的呢🤔\n总之，学了个样子，里子是一点都没学到。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/7c8d273ce191ea273115122908b4e85be0ecad08.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":997374,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"再来说重点，爱情。绅品里的女主们都是怎样的呢？热爱教学的纯真美女老师，看着轻浮其实自强自立的高尔夫选手，虽然是富二代但是自己也很努力的年轻设计师，还有全剧里我觉得最有魅力的富婆姐姐。因为喜欢就多说两句，区别于单薄的富婆设定，绅品中给她赋予了很多毛病，比如多疑任性爱发脾气，动不动就要离婚。但这些的背后是姐姐对年轻爱玩的正录的一次次包容，不仅帮助他开店，免去了他的兄弟们工作室的租金(富婆姐姐拥有一整条街的楼)，疼爱他兄弟的妹妹，替他兄弟的爱人出面解决校园纠纷...她几乎帮助了兄弟团成员及家属的每一个人。偶尔也叛逆一回，作为大姐头带着家属团去泡夜店，虽说最后被通通抓包了吧～可是敏淑姐姐实在可爱(最右那个)\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/4a29a0788bee7d7d831dc13eacda5a91b8d4355b.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1092694,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"绅品中的爱情线，都是曲折的双向奔赴的，因此才让人格外上头。比起东八里面爹味十足的发言，普通却自信的自我陶醉，还有那种除了他自己没有一个人觉得幽默的段子(吐舌头的图我就不放了，我多看一眼都是对眼睛的伤害)真是踏实太多了。既然这么多都借鉴了，麻烦你把感情怎么发展也学了吧！耍帅的前提是真帅，怎么就能这么做作呢？\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/0928480fc3eb563de6181bbe0f80ca43be0eed77.jpg","width":1920,"height":1080,"size":1000056,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"年龄差了10岁，油腻感都不能画等号啊...\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/c176bf229f5206dbcf941a1a7d3af658f9960b04.jpg","width":400,"height":600,"size":129944,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"东八的感情线，我甚至都不知道女主们究竟喜欢这群人哪里...除了资本压制，我找不到理由。咸猪手，跟踪，偷拍，过度YY对方的反应...真是心疼女演员们，太不容易了！\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/94890efe44370dd3258f917f15cb70934d24250c.jpg","width":640,"height":1385,"size":530701,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"这种危险发言，就该直接上去给他一个大B兜！🤬🤬🤬\n再看绅品的感情线发展。主线肯定是张东健饰演的金道振和金荷娜饰演的徐伊秀。徐最初喜欢的是自己曾经的学生回音的哥哥泰山，可偏偏泰山喜欢上了伊秀的朋友世拉。机缘巧合之下，撞到了泰山的合伙人金道振，而道振对她三见钟情，第一次想认真了解一个人，开始了漫长的暗恋之路。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/06758c649c97bae24c08a5dd6d1a14dc15d33995.jpg","width":1080,"height":662,"size":414172,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"(上图:是毛衣线先动的手)这一段真是既搞笑又有点小浪漫😆\n总是不正经的道振，终于用一次次诚恳的行动告诉依秀，自己的真心。最后还用第一次见面时的红毛线为她设计了房子，成功求婚\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/172c4a714e1000951209d49970abf0ff340f46b2.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1025622,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"不仅主线精彩，另外三对的爱恨情仇也同样精彩。泰山的坚定不移成功收服了倔强的世拉。坚持自己的爱恋的回音也终于抱得男神归，打消了崔润对二人年龄差的踟蹰。我们可爱的敏淑欧尼，和改邪归正的正录吵吵闹闹的继续过日子，还领养了好几个穷困儿童，真是整部剧里最有反差性魅力的角色。\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/2caa52dda2fa1a24f8790e1b3e6ff391bbbcb26e.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1174762,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"所以，对东八这剧失望至极的同学，不妨去看一下“原作”洗洗眼睛，同样的脱离现实，可一个是丑化，一个是美化。至少在韩国剧集的世界观里，女性多方面的魅力确实得到了渲染。(至于他们现实中的，呵呵，不多加评论了)\n"},{"attributes":{"class":"normal-img"},"insert":{"native-image":{"alt":"read-normal-img","url":"https://b1.sanwen.net/b_article/d11da7a57b9315b7a609d9ce6f64b22ce64a8c30.jpg","width":2340,"height":1080,"size":1034383,"status":"loaded"}}},{"insert":"好啦，不专业的影视剧小评到此结束，感谢每一个看到最后的朋友。爱你们❤️\n"}]}
标签：
